Repair them when the fault sits in one place — a loose hanger, a dripping corner, a low spot, a downspout that pulled apart. Replace them when failures run the length of the house: metal corroded through, joints that keep reopening, troughs too small for the roof, or rotted fascia behind them.
We look at the gutters and the wood behind them, then tell you which job it is.
Most gutter trouble shows up at one spot first: a corner that drips onto the steps, a run that droops between two hangers, a downspout lying in the flower bed. The real question is whether that spot is the whole problem or the first sign of a system wearing out.
Short answer: whether to repair or replace gutters comes down to where the fault is. Repair them when it is isolated and the metal is sound. Replace them when corrosion has gone through the trough, joints reopen soon after resealing, the gutters are too small for the roof above them, or the fascia behind them has rotted. Gutter Solutions LLC checks all four before recommending a repair or a full gutter replacement.
Any one of these can sometimes be managed for a while. Two or more across most of the house is the point where repairs stop paying for themselves.
Age matters less than metal and exposure. The run facing the salt wind off the marsh can be rusting through while the sheltered side of the same house is still sound, so judge each run by its condition, not its date.
When the metal and the wood behind it are still sound, these are the jobs a cleaning and repair visit handles without replacing anything but parts.
A single stretch droops, water collects in the low point, and the gutter pulls further with every storm. A spike has usually backed out, or a hanger has bent under wet leaves.
New hidden hangers screwed into sound wood on either side of the sag, the run lifted back into line and the fall checked with a hose.
Water runs down the siding below one corner, often with a dark streak on the fascia above it. The sealant at the miter or cap has split or let go.
Old sealant cut out, the joint cleaned to bare metal, re-riveted where it has worked loose and sealed again — or soldered, on copper.
A day or two after rain, part of the gutter still holds water and a line of silt. That section has lost its fall toward the outlet.
The low section re-hung to fall toward its outlet, or a second outlet cut in on a long run. On steel, the trough bottom is checked too: standing water is where rust starts.
A section has come apart, a strap has corroded through, or the outlet spills over during heavy rain because an elbow is packed with leaves or pine straw.
Elbows cleared and flushed, sections re-fastened with new straps, and a larger downspout fitted where a small one keeps backing up.
Find your symptom in the left column. The verdict is the usual outcome; the final call is made at the property.
| What you see | Usually | Likely cause | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Drip at one corner | Repair | Failed sealant at one joint | Reseal that joint; the rest is fine. |
| One span sagging | Repair | A loose spike or bent hanger | New hangers into sound wood. |
| Sagging everywhere | Replace | Spikes giving up, or soft fascia | Hangers fail faster than they can be chased. |
| Water left standing | Repair | Lost pitch toward the outlet | Re-hang the low section. |
| Overflow, trough clean | Replace | Too small for the roof above | No repair adds capacity. |
| Rust or pinholes | Replace | Corrosion in older steel | Each patch fails beside the next. |
| Seams leak again | Replace | Sectional splices moving | The joints are the flaw. |
| Rotted fascia | Wood first | Overflow soaking the board | Fix the board, then judge the gutter. |
| Limb-dented run | Replace that run | Impact on one wall | The other walls can stay. |
A guide to the usual outcome, not a diagnosis. Two or more “replace” rows across most of the house is the clearest sign that repairs have stopped making sense.
A gutter hangs on the fascia board, and when a trough overflows for years, the top edge of that board soaks up the water first. Paint can look fine from the lawn while the wood behind it has gone soft enough to push a screwdriver into.
Rot changes the order of work, not just the price. Hangers need sound timber to bite into, so soft sections are cut out and replaced before any gutter goes back up. It also changes the verdict: rotted fascia behind a sound aluminum gutter is a repair, while rotted fascia behind a rusting, undersized gutter is the strongest case for soffit and fascia repair and new gutters in one visit.
A new gutter screwed into a rotten board is just a repair bill with a delay on it. The wood gets fixed first.
Gutter Solutions LLC
On the islands and along the marsh, gutters age from the fasteners outward. Salt settles on everything, stays damp in humid air and goes to work on galvanized screws, steel straps and any cut edge where a coating stops. Summer heat does the rest, baking sealant until sectional joints open again soon after they are resealed.
Copper and aluminum should never touch; in salt air the aluminum corrodes where they meet. When an older system mixes metals, replacement is usually cleaner than another patch, and choosing a gutter metal for salt air is the first decision.
Several coastal towns review exterior changes in their historic districts. Like-for-like maintenance is usually the easy path; a new profile or metal can need a Certificate of Appropriateness first.
Exterior work downtown goes through Certificate of Appropriateness review. A December 2024 staff decision covered even the in-kind replacement of copper leader heads and downspouts on a Bull Street building.
Gutters around SavannahThe city lists replacing rotted wood with the same material as maintenance that needs no Certificate, while changes to a building’s exterior need an application to the Historic Preservation Board.
Brunswick and the Golden IslesA Certificate is required for alterations that change the exterior appearance, including exterior features that look different from the ones already on the building.
Homes in St. MarysThe city’s design guidelines exempt ordinary maintenance but send changes to exterior features to design review before a building permit — and they ask for eave treatments to be kept.
Gutters in McIntosh CountyPhotograph the existing gutters, downspouts and any leader heads, and check with the city before work begins. Where a district expects half-round or copper put back like for like, Gutter Solutions LLC forms that profile on site.
Five stages, in order. Nothing goes back up until the wood behind it is sound.
Each wall is measured for the roof area it drains, the fascia is probed along its length, and the estimate sets out profile, size, metal, outlets and discharge.
Troughs, spikes, straps and downspouts come off and leave on our truck, not at your curb, and old fastener holes are sealed.
Soft fascia and damaged soffit are cut out and replaced, and the drip edge is checked so roof water lands in the new gutter instead of behind it.
Each run is roll-formed at the property to the length of its wall, set to fall toward its outlets and fastened on hidden hangers into the repaired wood.
Downspouts are sized for the roof they serve, each one empties somewhere deliberate, and a hose run through the system proves the pitch before anyone packs up.
Two houses of the same size can need very different work, which is why every estimate starts with a tape measure.
Still have a question? The quickest answer is a phone call, and we will talk it through with you.
(912) 202-0537On the day, a repair nearly always costs less. Over a few seasons it depends on the fault. Fixing one leaking corner on a sound system is money well spent; paying every year to patch a system that is corroding or too small usually costs more than new seamless runs would have, and the problem never goes away. When the call is close, ask for both options in writing.
Only for an isolated fault on metal that is still solid. Galvanized steel relies on its zinc coating, and once rust shows along the bottom of the trough or at the seams, that coating is spent there. Patching one rust hole in a trough like that usually buys a season before the next one opens a few feet away.
No. It is usually a fastening problem: spikes that have backed out, or hangers screwed into wood that has gone soft. If the fascia is sound, new hidden hangers fix it. If the board has rotted, the wood is repaired first, and the gutter’s own condition decides whether it goes back up.
Not if the system is already failing. A tropical storm puts the heaviest load a gutter ever carries on its weakest hangers and joints, so a run that sags or leaks in June is likely to cause more damage by October. If the gutters are sound, a cleaning and the steps in our storm-prep checklist are enough to start the season with.
Yes. A repair starts with what is on the house now, whoever hung it. Gutter Solutions LLC re-hangs sagging runs, reseals corners and end caps, restores pitch and replaces downspout sections, and says plainly when a part is too far gone to be worth fixing.
Call or text and we will come out, look at the gutters and the wood behind them, and tell you plainly whether it is a repair or a replacement — with the scope written down either way.
Call or text(912) 202-0537Photo credits: russteaches, CC BY 2.0.
Forecasts and alerts from the National Weather Service · for planning gutter work, not safety decisions. Your approximate area is estimated from your IP address using a third-party lookup; you can pick a county above instead.
